Sunday, August 5, 2012

Post #3: The Complete Persepolis

Before diving, into this somewhat thick comic novel, I should inspect the cover. I assume the six people adorning the front are main characters around which the plot will be focused. Yet, I never give that much thought to front covers, as the saying goes, "do not judge a book by its cover". So, why do we? I like a good mystery. From not having seen the corresponding movie or ever hearing of the book outside of this class I Googled "persepolis" to find it is ...


"A city in ancient Persia, northeast of Shiraz. It was founded in the late 6th century bc by Darius I."
I am unsure of the connection between the title and story at hand, even after reading the entire book.

My impressions of Islam and gender, in relation to this religion, are nothing short of the uninformed stereotype. This makes me think of our classroom discussion when the burqa was brought up. I had heard, and even used this term before, as if it was universal, as if I really knew about it and the meaning, so I did a little research myself. Yet burquas are never actually talked about or even referred to in this graphic novel.
"The hijab is a headscarf worn over the head which covers the head and the hair. With the hijab, the face is seen."
Here the visual difference is presented along with several over fashions and ways of covering the head.



So this is actually what we are dealing with. The hijab immediately points to gender manipulation. Why must the women wear this and not the men? Is it to be said that men do not possess physical qualities rendering pleasure anymore than women? So I immediately feel sympathy towards women as they must "suffer" this loss of expression independence.

My immediate impressions of Christianity and its relation to gender are almost completely opposite. I consider myself a Christian and have been from an early age, so I am more educated on this religion and its stance on the treatment of gender. In the church women and men are viewed as equals. A man or a woman can become a pastor, minister, or any other range of church authority, yet I am not saying this church is perfect in any way. But a question I have always had is, why has God always been traditionally viewed as a man? Even in the Bible all of Jesus' Apostles are men. Women are also categorized early as property of men. I intend on researching this topic more for my final thoughts on "HOME". But this I may never know.

The things I know about Iran:
1. Third world country in the Middle East
2. Unstable government
3. Oil industry
4. Frequent war
I really do not know too much about Iran, its culture, or its people, yet I really enjoyed Persepolis and learning all that I can from this personal account on the Iranian culture.

When looking solely at the first and last pages of this book I imagine this story to contain a great deal of emotion. The first page shows strife from the pack of enraged people to the sparse smiles depicted. Flipping to the very last page there seems to be resolution shown by the quivering smiles and hopeful tears. I think this story will show the pursuits of a young girl growing into womanhood.

PERSEPOLIS AS A PORTRAIT OF CULTURE
RELIGION
The first discussion of religion is quick to come in the text. But the first sexist issue strikes a chord with me. Young Marji expresses to anyone that wants to knows that she wants to be the last prophet, and the illustration shows all men questioning, "a woman?"; this instantly shows deprivation that a female could ever be on the same religious level as a man.

I now turn to page 121, where the director of the hospital, in which Mr. Talischi is at after his third heart attack, which reveals not only disrespect towards women but a poor representation of fair religion. As this previous window washer claims, "...If God wills it, he'll get better. Everything depends on God."as reasoning to prevent this sick man from obtaining a passport to receive medical care outside of Iran. How is that okay? Is that even legal?

Religion seems to be depicted as such a depressive thing, if I may, from Marji's perspective. Looking at page 159, the nun asks Marji which denomination she is and when "none" is the response the nun does not seem too enthralled. Most everything is centered around religion or the lack thereof. but why?

Or how about on page 288, when it is said to be "against the religious moral code and the values of the republic" when Marjane marvels the hypothetical but rcommon issue among two young people that were not united by sacred ties. They would easily be fined and possibly whipped if showing any type of affection or relation to each other, outside of being family members.

SOCIAL CLASS

Is there a reason that most protesters are drawn as women? Yes, because most protesters were women. Women are viewed naturally inferior to men, especially in the Iranian culture, so of course they had the most rights taken away. I would surely protest myself. I realize this is not a case of social class, but that of gender binaries, yet in this case I feel that women are thrown into a social class less than that of men in every and all circumstances.

This is also highlighted in the section titled, "The Letter", when the courtship between the Satrapi's maid, Mehri, and their neighbors son is forbidden. This is expressed to young Marji by her father:
"You must understand that their love was impossible."
"Why is that?"
"Because in this country you must stay within your own social class."
"But is it her fault that she born where she was???"

Of course it is right of her father to tell Marji the truth, but is that philosophy right or wrong? What is right? What is wrong? Who is to say what is right or wrong?..

EDUCATION
I am very overwhelmed by all the different roles education takes in Iranian society. My first thoughts came on the second page of illustration, where the young boys and girls are already being separated in school, but why? Later I come to understanding the reasoning used to justify this act among many others used to oppress women.

Looking at the educational system during the revolution in Iran, Marji was unfazed by the nonsense imposed upon her by authoritative figures. She is expelled after becoming confrontational with her principal at only age fourteen. Not being able to resist herself, this out spoken young lady voiced her opinion again at her next school by questioning teachers which led to calls home. I do not blame her. What kind of education was she receiving? One with a male dominated curriculum, this being represented when the children are asked to rip pages right out of their textbooks as to not learn "other history", like it can just be changed or forgotten.

The importance of education in the Satrapi family is pushed to the limits when it is decided on page 147 that Marji would move to Austria so that she could obtain a better, more safe education outside of Iran. Making the decision to let a fourteen year old move out of the country alone, or even out of the house at that age, just shows how much is willing to be put on the line so that Marji could further her education.

I see why education is so valued by Marji and her family because when it comes down to it all it is about what a person knows. On page 177, when the nuns stab at Marji's "lack of manors"they proceed to dig deeper by saying, "It's true what they say about Iranians. They have no education." I applaud Marji and her quit wit to rebuttal the sharp tongued nun.

ROLES OF WOMEN

Where to begin when thinking of the roles of women in Iranian society. Most circumstances come down to the fact that women are objectified in one way or another. Page 100 gives two prime examples, the first being when paradise is explained to young boys at school. It is described as a place a martyr goes that has "plenty of food, women, and houses made of gold and diamonds." How can a human being be roped into a category with all other materialistic things including sustenance? Or when the boy is spoken to by Mrs. Satrapi when he comes home from school:
"Think about when you're grown up. You will go to college. You'll become somebody."
"I'll marry her!"

He has been taught to believe that he can pick and choose his property, which entails a woman, which awards him a slap across the face by his mother.

In concurrence to La Perdida I see women being represented as ignorant in several cases. I think of all the times Carla thought she knew how to be a Mexican, what being a Mexican felt like, and how she tried to appear as"Mexican-y". But she had no idea what she was talking about a good portion of the time. This pulls me to page 32 in Persepolis, when the old widow is confused why protesters were demonstrating on the terms of her husbands death. She knew he died from cancer, but all the protesters had to do was claim him "a hero" to hazily convince the woman to join in the chants.

Women are easily characterized as weak, physically and emotionally. Think of how frequently Carla was subjected to Memo's authority. Now to page 10 when young Marji admits "My faith was not unshakable". This can be displayed by a man or woman, but why are most coming-of-age stories plotted around a young woman who usually falters the most?

Turning to page 133, when the women's branch of the Guardians of the Revolution, whose "job was to put us back on the straight and narrow by explaining the duties of Muslim women" stop Marji. This is saddening because for as many women that protested officials there were just as many under hypnosis. Depicted here are women authorities oppressing young Marji for expressing herself - I can't even imagine.

How about page 336, when Behzad shows signs of being patriarchal towards his wife Mandana. While conversing with Gila and Marjane he simply would not let Mandana get a word in. Finishing her sentences for her stunted her freedom of speech, which showed a lack of respect by Behzad. This is followed by an epiphany on the next page where Marjane rants about the truth of reality that in their culture all laws side with the male perspective, as she exclains, "I CAN'T TAKE IT ANYMORE. I WANT TO LEAVE THIS COUNTRY?"

FAMILY

According to Marjane Satrapi family is extremely important in Iranian society. Her family members provided lovable and much needed support. It provided history she could be proud of. The only opinions that mattered to her were those of close friends and family whom which were able to give logical and practical reasoning which fed young Marji's desire to learn more about her family, its history, and the world around her.

DIFFERENCE IN CULTURE

I think the key differences between the way in which Marji was raised and that of Western culture rear its head on page 180, on the section titled "The Pill". Here contraceptives are introduced to represent the "more loose" sexual moralities of Westernized women. The thought of having sex before marriage in Iranian culture is unspeakable. The prevalence of make-up and being "done up" are rare to illegal in Iran as opposed to Julie and her mature ways. Modesty is the way of the Iranian woman unlike the acts of Marji and Julie on page 184 when Julie gives Marji a makeover and they speak freely of "a pussy" being paradise.

On this page Julie also disregards her mothers authority as she proceeds to leave her house on her own terms. Marji seems pretty confused and appalled at this act as she would never speak in that manor towards her parents - very different from her culture.

How about page 185, when Marji experiences her first party in Vienna which happened to be quite different from the parties back home. "In Iran, at parties, everyone would dance and eat. In Vienna, people preferred to lie around and smoke."

Marjane concludes the section, "The Pill", by showing her experience of learning what male testicles are. Also experiencing first hand Julie hooking up with a man helped Marji to understand the sexual revolution, and saw this as her "first big step toward assimilating into western culture."

After pretending to smoke regularly with her new friends on page 192 & page 193 we start to see Marji question and struggle with her new found image.
"The harder I tried to assimilate, the more I had the feeling that I was distancing myself from my culture, betraying my parents and my origins, that I was playing a game by somebody else's rules."

I see other frequent themes of violence, power struggle, and especially that of
death in this novel.

Tying together the theme of Women and Writing  in relation to this graphic novel think back to Marji's "holy book" on page 7 or her comic books that informed and inspired her on page 12. And writing does not happen without reading, and how prevalent is this when Marji goes through rough spells in her life she always pulls herself to the surface by turning back to reading.

In conclusion, when looking at the last pages of Persepolis, Marjane's father tells her, "We Iranians, we're crushed not only by the government but by the weight of our traditions!" (339) I think Marjane's parents and grandmother choose to stay in the repressive society of Iran for the pure reason he already stated. Most adults become stuck in their ways, loving the irreversible mold of routine and tradition. Even though the Iranian traditions are appalling (in some thoughts) it is all they know. Marjane already had the luxury of experiencing any other culture besides that of her childhood, Westernized culture at that, and now could no longer could stand the confines of her homeland government. Leaving does not seem that difficult for her family, but they oddly rather stay in that environment, in their comfort zone, for the rest of their lives.


http://www.differencebetween.net/miscellaneous/culture-miscellaneous/difference-between-a-hijab-and-a-burqa/

Monday, July 30, 2012

Post #2: La Perdida


     La Perdida when translated through Google an array of searches come up. How had I read through an entire book without fully acknowledging or exploring this mysterious title first? Why were many Spanish terms and places identified and translated in the glossary but the own title was missing in action? When translated this short phrase literally means "loose woman". This can be interpreted many different ways. Carla can be viewed as being loose, which may not necessarily be a compliment to the character, in her morals and life decisions. From Carla's defensive nature to back up about Memo as a person and friend to her reluctant manor to keep him and Oscar around at all it is made evident by Abel that Carla knows better but is choosing to be lackadaisical, even when it comes to her initial purpose and reason to venture to Mexico in the first place. On the other hand I can also relate to Carla seeking this nonchalant, carefree lifestyle. I can see myself in my 20s wanting to do more, feel more, be more - even though I do not consider my life anything short of great, living the free natured lifestyle is something everyone should experience at least once in their life.

     Comparing the different coming of age story plots of Bechdel and Abel I can see similar qualities and others more interesting. Bechdel reaches out from the Little House on the Prairie journey and chooses one that takes the reader into a more personal story of the graphic narrative. While Abel can express another coming of age story but further along the journey to becoming an adult. Making decisions that become life experiences that make you learn more about life and yourself. It's life. Abel also plays with the idea of making the reader look outside themselves and see that there are many people out in the world that are also going through the same experiences I am. Creating a commonality behind a group of readers is built by the intended audience of Mexican and/or American women, and  any opportunity for any woman seeking a good read will feel.


     When I think of writing in La Perdida I instantly think outside of the box. I think of the form of communication used by Carla and her brother Rod. They called each other but in spats as if the characters were to write to each other as well. As in journaling would include highlights and details of one's life (at home) to keep the other up to speed, as did Alison Bechdel but to keep her life in details and highlights she'd use later on to create Fun Home. It all seems that every story plot comes back to bases the foundation of the plot in what the characters identify as home. What is the relationship between the character and their "home".


     The usage of gender is different between these two comics. Bechdel approaches the clash of one's identity, sexuality, and classified gender roles. While Abel puts in concepts of stereotypes of the male gender and of Mexican culture. In Fun Home I looked at "home" as a physical establishment of where a person resides but more so of the feeling that one feels "at home". Bruce Bechdel used the house as a physical cover up to her second life compared to Carla feeling "at home" exploring her Mexican heritage. La Perdida questioned home as more of an establishment, or of a town or city, but one's own country. Making me question myself, how do other people in the world interpret their own feelings and concepts of home.

     I appreciated the different artist comic techniques of the two but preferred that on Fun Home, but only due to the way the message was delivered. The point of view in Fun Home varied while focusing more on the first person and from behind the eyes of Alison, but in La Perdida in view of solely the comics (not including the text) was from the third person seeing Carla act out her life and not through her eyes. Reading La Perdida can make one feel as very conversational taking the role of each character, feeling as if you were reading a raw script, presenting emotions of the characters that way. Then different from Fun Home which has more of a narrative approach speaking about a story and not apart of it.

I can highly relate myself to Carla. I would enjoy just packing up and diving into an unknown culture. Carla was seeking more and pushing the boundaries of her life to grow and see the world. I myself like routine but more so the spontaneous acts of life. Carla seems to let decisions follow the next sort of a free spirit through life never really liberating change in the path. I take comfort in God and knowing everything happens for a reason and there is also some lesson to be learned and every day is a gift. I can easily say I relate most to Carla's yearning for adventure.

Definitions:

Colonialism: The policy or practice of acquiring full or partial political control over another country, occupying it with settlers, and exploiting it economically

Neo-colonialism: NEW policy or practice of acquiring full or partial political control over another country, occupying it with settlers, and exploiting it economically

Capitalism: An economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state

Marxism: (marxism) the economic and political theories of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels that hold that human actions and institutions are economically determined and that class struggle is needed to create historical change and that capitalism will ultimately be superseded by communism




Sunday, July 22, 2012

Post #1: Fun Home


Directions: Critical reaction to either Fun Home or "The Laugh of the Medusa" (Cixous), or a combination of the two. What I expect of a critical reaction is serious thoughtful engagement in the text. Practice some of the moves we are encountering in Joseph Harris's book. I am more interested in analysis than in argumentation, so aim for complexity and reflection rather than simply an opinion on whether so and so is right or wrong. Think about what the authors are doing, and experiment yourself with what you want to do with your writing. Blogs are a great place to experiment. Have fun.

    Fun Home, the first graphic narrative memoir I have ever read. The first chapter book I may have ever read and actually enjoyed since elementary school (maybe because illustration was involved?). I sometimes think illustration takes creative power away from the reader as images have already been generated and faces have already been put to characters, but I think the adult comic approach gives the author and reader other ways to look at the text on many different levels, as so will I.

     I'd like to start off by analyzing solely the significance of the title. Fun. Home. Looking at the two terms separately it is easily to say that Fun might have been used to abbreviate Funeral as in Funeral Home which is obviously where a portion of the plots settings occur. Bruce himself gave his family employment the nickname of Fun Home to appeal to the children who would give their free labor there. But also the underlying irony. The house in which Alison and her family grow up in was never literally or figuratively called fun. It was a museum, library, and garden but never the people, nor the scenarios, were characterized in any way as fun. Then looking at "Home". The in depth meaning for this word is overwhelming in my opinion. Who is to say what a home is or where a home should be. Home is a physical residence of where a person or family may "live", but what can characterize a home. Home can be under a bridge, in a box...did Alison ever consider herself "at home"? Characterizing home as a feeling and not a noun is also another spin on the word. The significance of "home" in this memoir gives the reader the opportunity to look at one familiar word in many other contexts. The physical home was an outlet for Bruce Bechdel where he could express his interior/exterior decorative passion. It was also a place for him to hide his double life. Home was a place where he could appear to be one person, a hardworking family man, while disguising the alter ego he had created for himself. Home for Mrs. Bechdel became a place, towards the end of the book, which she outwardly expressed to Alison as a place she needed to leave. "I'm sick of cooking for him, and I'm sick of cleaning this museum..I can't stand it anymore. This house is a tinderbox", and where Alison empathetically coincides, "You've done enough. You should go." The interpretations of the title and the words that make it up all have multiple meanings, some of which are purposeful and some which are unintended.

     Fun Home does fall into the category of a "coming of age" story, but in several ways pushes the boundaries of this genre. Of course the usual subjects of puberty, body exploration, and family life/struggle are clearly represented, but the author is not writing a tale from The Baby-Sitter's Club. Here topics are not fluffed but told bluntly regarding graphic material such as gender, sexuality, and some "adult" experiences. The author does stick to the genre conventions familiarity, but strays away from the traditional, to build off of what we as readers already know by going deeper, more personable, and more relatable.

     Critically looking at how the story was structured and organized is delightfully complex. A style used here, which I would call story-overlapping, occurred a few times where the text and comic were running parallel but not identical to each other; where two different stories were being told in different ways and at different part, yet intertwined simultaneously.This intricate technique helped tell the unusual plot sequence which jumped around, while I had imagined the book to be told full circle was surprisingly fulfilling. In this occasion I do not see it necessary to be able to plot the storyline. I think this approach was innovative and captivates the reader, while keeping them on their toes. Reading comprehension is tested and worked, as the ability to flip back and forth while tagging new information to previously learned details is quite the skill in itself. 

     The topics gender and sexuality rear their heads exultantly in this memoir. Traditional, stereotypical gender roles are pushed, altered, and exposed. More formally decorative chores, gardening, and fussing of children's physical appearances would all be characterized tendencies of a mother or at least female, yet these are all integrated into Bruce's character. Usually a young girl like Alison would have wanted to play with dolls, steer clear of camping, and have been naturally into female fashion, yet Alison preferred men's fashion and fulfilling spare time with exploring her curious nature about her constant surroundings. Alison's childhood is a journey the reader takes with her in discovering herself and self identification as a lesbian. For some unexposed to this subject, may not know or are uninformed how a person comes into this state, or why, or how. Some readers may dislike this creature and its path chosen altogether because "it's not right" and many other variations of this. Sexuality can never be discussed without looking at both angles. I myself have a 19 year old cousin who recently came out a lesbian and reaction from my aunt was not far from that of Mrs. Bechdel's. Theories of "being confused", "being in a phase", and complete denial occurred until my cousin's girlfriend was introduced to the family much like Joan was. All personal experiences that hold weight to any individual going "against the grain" and being "untraditional" are all memorable.

     In many scenarios throughout the story I felt very drawn to Alison's character. After finishing the first chapter I was so spooked by the list of parallelisms already, I began to cry. From playing airplane  with an emotionally unresponsive father, yet only when there is an outburst like Bruce would have, to the physical likeness of a weathered, chest haired, jorts (jean pants cut into shorts) wearing man. From his outdoors manic manor to my fathers compulsive tidy tendencies. From the childhood bathing routine to myself sitting upon his lap while driving the tractor. The childhood similarities are staggering. Even though I only have one older brother I stuck with him, expressing tomboy characteristics early on. Hobbies included hiking, camping, fishing, boating, riding my bike, and outdoor games. My closet was adorned with many articles in my favorite color, blue, while being  sprinkled with my favorite plaid and camouflage button downs. I could be found, when I'd run off, exploring my back yard and climbing my favorite tree. Much as Alison disliked dresses, I remember like yesterday, my mother waking me up on a Sunday morning to go to church, standing beside my bed with a pink dress. I hurled my leg at her in every attempt to keep the dreaded girly contraption at bay. One difference though between Alison and I, though later in her life, her mother finally wanted a divorce, but my parents divorced when I was five years old. So in the way Bruce hid his alter life, my father exposed his raging alcoholism early enough as so my mother could escape the looming tinderbox.

     I absolutely loved Fun Home. This is the first story/book I have been able to say I really could not put down. Aside from the easy read I think this is a perfect choice for a fast summer class that still feeds the reader.


Here I can be found hanging from one my familiar trees with my step-sister Alex. Top right: lighting the advent wreath with my brother Troy and step-sister Alex wearing my favorite Fox motocross jersey. Bottom right: I had the shortest hair of any girl in my preschool class. I regularly took scissors to my own hair along with Barbie dolls and even trying to snip my own cats whiskers!