Directions: Critical reaction to either Fun Home or "The Laugh of the Medusa" (Cixous), or a combination of the two. What I expect of a critical reaction is serious thoughtful engagement in the text. Practice some of the moves we are encountering in Joseph Harris's book. I am more interested in analysis than in argumentation, so aim for complexity and reflection rather than simply an opinion on whether so and so is right or wrong. Think about what the authors are doing, and experiment yourself with what you want to do with your writing. Blogs are a great place to experiment. Have fun.
Fun Home, the first graphic narrative memoir I have ever read. The first chapter book I may have ever read and actually enjoyed since elementary school (maybe because illustration was involved?). I sometimes think illustration takes creative power away from the reader as images have already been generated and faces have already been put to characters, but I think the adult comic approach gives the author and reader other ways to look at the text on many different levels, as so will I.
I'd like to start off by analyzing solely the significance of the title. Fun. Home. Looking at the two terms separately it is easily to say that Fun might have been used to abbreviate Funeral as in Funeral Home which is obviously where a portion of the plots settings occur. Bruce himself gave his family employment the nickname of Fun Home to appeal to the children who would give their free labor there. But also the underlying irony. The house in which Alison and her family grow up in was never literally or figuratively called fun. It was a museum, library, and garden but never the people, nor the scenarios, were characterized in any way as fun. Then looking at "Home". The in depth meaning for this word is overwhelming in my opinion. Who is to say what a home is or where a home should be. Home is a physical residence of where a person or family may "live", but what can characterize a home. Home can be under a bridge, in a box...did Alison ever consider herself "at home"? Characterizing home as a feeling and not a noun is also another spin on the word. The significance of "home" in this memoir gives the reader the opportunity to look at one familiar word in many other contexts. The physical home was an outlet for Bruce Bechdel where he could express his interior/exterior decorative passion. It was also a place for him to hide his double life. Home was a place where he could appear to be one person, a hardworking family man, while disguising the alter ego he had created for himself. Home for Mrs. Bechdel became a place, towards the end of the book, which she outwardly expressed to Alison as a place she needed to leave. "I'm sick of cooking for him, and I'm sick of cleaning this museum..I can't stand it anymore. This house is a tinderbox", and where Alison empathetically coincides, "You've done enough. You should go." The interpretations of the title and the words that make it up all have multiple meanings, some of which are purposeful and some which are unintended.
Fun Home does fall into the category of a "coming of age" story, but in several ways pushes the boundaries of this genre. Of course the usual subjects of puberty, body exploration, and family life/struggle are clearly represented, but the author is not writing a tale from The Baby-Sitter's Club. Here topics are not fluffed but told bluntly regarding graphic material such as gender, sexuality, and some "adult" experiences. The author does stick to the genre conventions familiarity, but strays away from the traditional, to build off of what we as readers already know by going deeper, more personable, and more relatable.
Critically looking at how the story was structured and organized is delightfully complex. A style used here, which I would call story-overlapping, occurred a few times where the text and comic were running parallel but not identical to each other; where two different stories were being told in different ways and at different part, yet intertwined simultaneously.This intricate technique helped tell the unusual plot sequence which jumped around, while I had imagined the book to be told full circle was surprisingly fulfilling. In this occasion I do not see it necessary to be able to plot the storyline. I think this approach was innovative and captivates the reader, while keeping them on their toes. Reading comprehension is tested and worked, as the ability to flip back and forth while tagging new information to previously learned details is quite the skill in itself.
The topics gender and sexuality rear their heads exultantly in this memoir. Traditional, stereotypical gender roles are pushed, altered, and exposed. More formally decorative chores, gardening, and fussing of children's physical appearances would all be characterized tendencies of a mother or at least female, yet these are all integrated into Bruce's character. Usually a young girl like Alison would have wanted to play with dolls, steer clear of camping, and have been naturally into female fashion, yet Alison preferred men's fashion and fulfilling spare time with exploring her curious nature about her constant surroundings. Alison's childhood is a journey the reader takes with her in discovering herself and self identification as a lesbian. For some unexposed to this subject, may not know or are uninformed how a person comes into this state, or why, or how. Some readers may dislike this creature and its path chosen altogether because "it's not right" and many other variations of this. Sexuality can never be discussed without looking at both angles. I myself have a 19 year old cousin who recently came out a lesbian and reaction from my aunt was not far from that of Mrs. Bechdel's. Theories of "being confused", "being in a phase", and complete denial occurred until my cousin's girlfriend was introduced to the family much like Joan was. All personal experiences that hold weight to any individual going "against the grain" and being "untraditional" are all memorable.
In many scenarios throughout the story I felt very drawn to Alison's character. After finishing the first chapter I was so spooked by the list of parallelisms already, I began to cry. From playing airplane with an emotionally unresponsive father, yet only when there is an outburst like Bruce would have, to the physical likeness of a weathered, chest haired, jorts (jean pants cut into shorts) wearing man. From his outdoors manic manor to my fathers compulsive tidy tendencies. From the childhood bathing routine to myself sitting upon his lap while driving the tractor. The childhood similarities are staggering. Even though I only have one older brother I stuck with him, expressing tomboy characteristics early on. Hobbies included hiking, camping, fishing, boating, riding my bike, and outdoor games. My closet was adorned with many articles in my favorite color, blue, while being sprinkled with my favorite plaid and camouflage button downs. I could be found, when I'd run off, exploring my back yard and climbing my favorite tree. Much as Alison disliked dresses, I remember like yesterday, my mother waking me up on a Sunday morning to go to church, standing beside my bed with a pink dress. I hurled my leg at her in every attempt to keep the dreaded girly contraption at bay. One difference though between Alison and I, though later in her life, her mother finally wanted a divorce, but my parents divorced when I was five years old. So in the way Bruce hid his alter life, my father exposed his raging alcoholism early enough as so my mother could escape the looming tinderbox.
I absolutely loved Fun Home. This is the first story/book I have been able to say I really could not put down. Aside from the easy read I think this is a perfect choice for a fast summer class that still feeds the reader.
Here I can be found hanging from one my familiar trees with my step-sister Alex. Top right: lighting the advent wreath with my brother Troy and step-sister Alex wearing my favorite Fox motocross jersey. Bottom right: I had the shortest hair of any girl in my preschool class. I regularly took scissors to my own hair along with Barbie dolls and even trying to snip my own cats whiskers!

No comments:
Post a Comment